Skip to main content

Tibetans : From Refugees to Voters

Tibetans : From Refugees to Voters

December 23, 2014
Tibetan refugees who were born in India between January 26, 1950 and July 1, 1987 now enjoy the right to vote for the ensuing Delhi Assembly elections as per a December 8 order of the Election Commission of India to Delhi’s Chief Electoral Officer. Other states too will soon follow the line once the electoral rolls are revised.
Tibetans From Refugees to Voters
The decision does not have the government’s consent but is legally valid as India’s citizenship law is very clear that the people born in India before July 1, 1987 and their children are citizens by birth.

Tibetans’ Right to Indian Citizenship Upheld by Courts

The issue of citizenship to Tibetan refugees though came into prominence following judgements on the issue of refugee status of Tibetans born in India between the stipulated period, in two separate yet identical cases respectively by the High Courts of Delhi in December 2010, and Karnataka in August 2013.  Both the High court rulings upheld the Tibetan petitioners’ right to an Indian passport as per the provisions under the country’s Citizenship Act, 1955.
The landmark judgments had much larger ramifications. They implied that the Tibetan refugees qualified for Indian passport also had the right to vote in Indian elections. The Election Commission wrote on February 7, 2014 to all states to enrol Tibetan refugees, born in India between the stipulated period, as voters, before the April-May 2014 General Elections. But a large section of Tibetans could not exercise their franchise as their documents could not be verified on time.
Another significant implication of the Delhi High Court judgement was with regard to job provisions for them in India. Citing the judgement, the Indian Nursing Council allowed Tibetan nurses born in India before July 1, 1987, to be registered with it so that they could practise their profession.
While little over one lakh Tibetan refugees live in India making India the largest host of Tibetans in exile, more than 35,000 Tibetans born between 1956 and 1987 now stand to qualify to be Indian citizens.

Indian citizenship and voting rights for Tibetans: A Complex Issue

The issue of Indian citizenship and voting rights for Tibetans is rather more complex and is involved in technicalities. In principle, neither the Indian government nor the Central Tibetan Administration (CTA or the Tibetan government in exile) appreciates such a move. Even the Election Commission acknowledges that the Indian Ministry of Home Affairs – the nodal ministry for the Citizenship Act – is “against giving voting rights to refugees in India…”
Reportedly, the China angle is quite significant for the government but Beijing had remained mum on both the Delhi and Karnataka high court rulings in the past.

Tibetans: No More Refugees Now?

Another question that is being raised now is: whether the Tibetans simultaneously enjoy both the status of refugees and citizens at the same time. But the status of Tibetans as refugees in India has been debatable since India is not a party to the 1951 United Nations Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees or its 1967 protocol. Besides India does not have any specific legislation about refugee rights and protection either. The Tibetans in India are provided a registration card under the Foreigners Act of 1946 and they are required to register themselves at a Foreigner Registration Office every year (in some cases, every five years) to extend their stay here.
As of now, the Tibetan government-in-exile issues each Tibetan a “Green Book, which is proof of their original nationality”. The CTA, though, leaves the decision to apply for Indian or any other country’s citizenship to the individuals and considers that to be a “personal choice”.
The Tibetan Prime Minister-in-exile Dr Lobsang Sangay, who incidentally is himself a US Green Cardholder, recently told an interviewer that the CTA “cannot compel” any Tibetan to apply for Indian citizenship “as the application process entails surrendering both Registration Certificate (RC) and Identity Certificate (IC) documents to the Indian authorities”.
The request for NOCs by India-born Tibetans though has thus far been very less as many still see voting in Indian elections as the dilution of the dream of a Free Tibet. Will this perception change now?
Given their insignificant numbers, Tibetans cannot emerge as a ‘vote bank’. Yet, as citizens, they may be able to buy land in their adopted country – a privilege that they could not enjoy as a foreign refugee.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Expectations from Chinese President Xi Jinping’s India Visit

Expectations from Chinese President Xi Jinping’s India Visit By  Deepak Parvatiyar September 5, 2014 Much is expected of the ensuing India visit of the Chinese President Xi Jinping both on strategic and economic fronts. Indian Commerce Minister Nirmala Seetharaman visited Beijing at the same time when Prime Minister Narendra Modi was in Japan. India expects Jinping’s visit to pave the way for major Chinese investments in the country, while also hoping China to facilitate Indian IT services exports by removing the barriers. Border dispute between the two countries too are expected to figure in the summit meet. China High on India’s Agenda There is no doubt that China is crucial to the Modi government’s foreign policy. Vice President Hamid Ansari had visited Beijing in June this year (Seetharaman had accompanied Ansari to China then too). At that time both countries had signed a Memorandum of Understanding on facilitating Chinese industrial parks in India...
Post a Comment
Read more

Campaigning in Karnataka had a definite pattern

Campaigning in Karnataka had a definite pattern By Deepak Parvatiyar The Marathi translation of this was published in Marathi Daily Pudhari on 12 May 2018  http://newspaper.pudhari.co.in/viewpage.php?edn=Kolhapur&date=2018-05-12&edid=PUDHARI_KOL&pid=PUDHARI_KOL&pn=8#Article/PUDHARI_KOL_20180512_08_2/446px/1A764FD No holds barred campaigning that at times stooped to the levels of personal attacks, and the Rs.100 crore legal notice slapped by the incumbent CM, Siddaramaiah on Prime Minister Narendra Modi, were some of the features of the high voltage electioneering in Karnataka that goes to polls on Saturday. But the unearthing of a Voter ID card scam towards the end of the electioneering would remembered more in Karnataka. The seizure of nearly 10,000 voter ID cards from an apartment in Bengaluru’s Jalahari area is a pointer to the efforts of political parties to rig the elections. These ID cards were purchased from poor voters, so that they could...
Post a Comment
Read more

Reporters Vs Byte Collectors – The dilemma of news television in India

Reporters Vs Byte Collectors – The dilemma of news television in India By Deepak Parvatiyar (This article was published in Sahara news portal in 2009) In an open letter on the web to the National Broadcasters Association ( a body representing many of major news channels of the country) recently, BV Rao, who happened to be my editor in Free Press Journal in the early nineties, wrote about the superficiality of news television while lamenting the way the Mumbai terror attack was covered on the Television. “We could have cut down heavily on the empty hyperbole and lent substance and sobriety to the proceedings,” he mourned. Is that possible? For years…ever since the initiation of private news channels in the nineties…TV news content is on a gradual yet phenomenal decay.  If we thought we could beat BBC or CNN, our reporters woefully lack their exposure and experience. The more our tv journo try to ape them, the more they expose their limitations…and foolhardines...
Post a Comment
Read more