Skip to main content

Religious Conversions: Embarrassment or Gain for BJP?

Religious Conversions: Embarrassment or Gain for BJP?

December 13, 2014
The issue of forcible conversions is in eye of a storm again following the conversion of 300 Muslims to Hinduism in Agra by militant Hindu groups Bajrang Dal and Dharma Jagaran Manch earlier this week.

blog_1

Conversions Vs Re-conversions

The Hindutva brigade now claims that it has been a case of ‘re-conversion’ after the Agra episode created a ruckus both in Parliament and outside it.
Unruffled, these outfits even plan more such conversions even as the Agra episode has sparked a row with the Muslim groups claiming that those (re)converted there were actually offered BPL (Below Poverty Line) and ration cards.

Vajpayee had Tactfully Handled the Conversion Issue

On 11 January 1999, the then Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee had called for a national debate on the issue of religious conversions.
He was at that time on a visit to the troubled Dangs district of Gujarat following reports of Hindu-Christian clashes over the issue of forced conversions in the predominantly tribal district.
By calling for a debate, Vajpayee deftly handled the issue in the wake of the mounting pressure on him from the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh backed Hindu outfits – the Vishwa Hindu Parishad and the Bajrang Dal, as well as another Sangh outfit, the Vansvasi Kalayan Ashram that too was allegedly involved in such conversions in Dangs.
He had then turned down the Opposition demands of banning the activities of the VHP and the Dal, and put the onus on the collectors and superintendents of police for the protection of life and property of all, and that included the minorities.

Conversions Vs Home Coming

The Hindutva forces accuse leaders of other religions of forcibly converting Hindus through coercion or by luring them with money. They claim they indulge in getting these converted people to reconvert to Hinduism and call this process as ‘ Ghar Vapasi (home coming)’.
Reports suggest that the RSS and its affiliates have been involved in such re-conversions for the last 50 years at least.

The RSS and its Concept of Hindutva

If one carefully analyses the speech of the RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat’s Gurupurnima day speech in July last year, then the RSS’s interpretation of Hindutva and Hindu Rashtra seems interspersed with India’s pluralistic society and its idea of unity in diversity .
This perhaps explains the proclamation of BJP leader and Union minister Venkaiah Naidu in Parliament during the heated debate on the Agra conversion issue that he was “proud” of his RSS background.
Yet, the inherent flaw in the approach, whether by default or design, is the RSS’s definition of a Hindu. Bhagwat has already courted enough controversy by stating that except for the Jews and the Parsis, “everybody’s ancestors in India were Hindus”.
Whether such a definition of Hindu trespasses the domain of fundamental right to propagate one’s religion is a matter of debate. But doesn’t such a statement by any leader inspire awe in a multi-ethnic-multi-religious nation?
The trouble starts when the so-called hardliners of the extended Sangh Parivar gleefully lap such words for political gains. A recent case in point is the BJP Member of Parliament Yogi Adityanath who announced his plans to carry out an Agra-like (re)conversion ceremony in Aligarh on the Christmas day. His action has a motif. Consider his remarks that he made in September this year that “… where they are more than 35%, there is no place for non-Muslims”.
Was he suggesting conversion then?
Modi Government at the Receiving End
It is no fluke that the issue of conversions surfaces more during the BJP regimes. Ever after the Babri mosque demolition, communalism has proved to be the BJP’s Achilles’ heel time and again. The Agra episode now provides the Opposition an opportunity to drag Prime Minister Narendra Modi into the controversy. In Parliament, the Opposition did seek to trap Modi by demanding his intervention on the issue. It was a shrewd political ploy to target the PM, given the fact that even Modi had been an RSS Pracharak and a strong proponent of Hindu nationalism.
Will Modi intervene on the issue? After all, Vajpayee did instruct him to perform his “Raj Dharma” as the then Chief Minister of Gujarat when communal violence had broken out there!

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

WANTED: A Leader

WANTED: A Leader EDITORIAL NEWS Share on facebook Share on blogger Share on linkedin Share on twitter More Sharing Services 31 WANTED: A Leader June 13, 2012 12:15 PM By Deepak Parvatiyar Do we really have any leader in our country who is above religion, caste, and sectarian politics and yet popular with the masses? Can you name any one name that is acceptable to the majority as a mass leader? My question assumes significance in the wake of what we witnessed last week. First, at the Congress Working Committee meeting the delegates raked up the issue of inaccessible ministers (how can they be leaders if they are inaccessible?) Yet, the most important issue was the lack of unanimity even within the ruling coalition itself over the choice of the next Presidential candidate. Thereafter, the BJP’s Gujarat satrap Narendra Modi delivered a power packed punch to claim the scalp of his little-known-much-discussed and elusive bête noire Sanjay Joshi. (Can Modi ...

Why election manifestos are losing their value and importance in India?

Why election manifestos are losing their value and importance in India? By  Deepak Parvatiyar March 11, 2015 Much ruckus is being made on the coming together of the two diametrically opposite parties, the Jammu and Kashmir People’s Democratic Party and the  Bharatiya Janata Party , to form the government in Jammu and Kashmir. Inarguably they are two uncomfortable allies who in any given circumstances are considered ideologically misfit to join hands lest rule together. The initial jerks in the coalition have already surfaced after the J&K PDP’s mentor and new state chief minister Mufti Mohammed Sayeed arbitrarily decided to release hard-line Kashmiri separatist Masarat Alam from detention, recently. This has put the BJP in the dock and it now cries foul over not being consulted on the issue. The Opposition has even forced adjournments in both the houses of Parliament over the issue demanding an explanation from the BJP-led Union Government. The BJP is ...

Summary of Second Phase of Assam and Bengal polls

Summary of Second Phase of Assam and Bengal polls By Deepak Parvatiyar http://www.elections.in/blog/summary-second-phase-assam-bengal-polls/ April 11, 2016 An FIR was filed against Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi (Congress) under Section 126 of the Representation of People’s Act at the direction of the Election Commission for violating the model code of conduct by holding a press conference in Guwahati during the second phase of polling in the state. The allegations made by Gogoi during the press conference were found unfounded by the Commission which viewed the press conference as an exercise to influence the polling. Voter Turnout in Assam State polls in Assam concluded with 82.02% of 1,04,35,277 voters turning out at the 12,699 polling stations by 5 pm, to seal the fate of 525 candidates in 61 assembly constituencies of the state. The polling percentage was much higher than the 76.05% recorded in these constituencies in 2011 state elections and the 80.21% poll...