Skip to main content

Narendra Modi’s Teachers’ Day Speech - Lofty ideals with a political agenda?

Narendra Modi’s Teachers’ Day Speech

September 6, 2014
http://www.elections.in/blog/narendra-modis-teachers-day-speech/


Consider the impact that Narendra Modi’s Teachers’ Day address could have on young impressionistic minds of school going children! Wouldn’t it have a lasting impression? We have seen US President Barrack Obama interacting with students at St Xavier’s College, Mumbai during his India visit and we still remember it. Yet, Modi’s interaction with students is more ubiquitous because of his choice of the date – the Teachers’ Day!
Narendra Modi’s Teachers’ Day Address

Modi’s Teachers’ Day Address :  Meticulous Exercise

Wasn’t his live address to millions of students across the country through electronic mediums and digital technology a grand spectacle? It did require meticulous planning and swift execution and Modi effectively displayed that he is a great organiser of spectacular events.
School timings were shifted when Modi addressed from New Delhi’s Manekshaw Auditorium in the presence of about 1,000 students of government-run Sarvodaya Vidyalayas. Considering an impatient young audience, his address was short and crisp and more time was assigned to the interaction session with students of different states via video conferencing.
His move is being eulogised by his supporters, who point out that this was unprecedented that school children from across the country openly shared their views and exchanged their ideas with any Prime Minister. Modi himself acknowledged during his almost two-hour-long interaction, that never before were the school students seen occupying so much space on television screens!
Why did Modi not choose Children’s Day ?
Yet his opponents are wary of his move. Congress leader Manish Tewari has gone to the extent of appealing parents that they should challenge the circulars on Modi’s speech to be telecast in the school in the court and that such a step is legally incorrect.
Wouldn’t it have been more apt for the Prime Minister to address the school children on 14thNovember – the birthday of India’s first Prime Minister Chacha (Jawahar Lal) Nehru – celebrated as Children’s Day? Was there politics involved in the selection of the day?
We celebrate 5th September as Teachers’ Day to pay our homage to our former President Dr Sarvapalli Radhakrishnan – a great teacher himself. Isn’t this a day meant to pay our respect to teachers who play more important role in our development than anyone else?
So, instead of students, wouldn’t it have been more apt for Modi to address teachers live through digital technology across the country and address their problems? Wouldn’t it have been a better tribute to our teachers and a morale booster to them considering the pitiable conditions a majority of them live in? Isn’t it true that teaching in our country – particularly teaching in schools – is not a preferred vocation?
In an apparent justification of his move, Modi said in his address –“-The importance of Teachers’ Day is diminishing. The day has just been reduced to be focussed on teachers getting awards…”

Why Modi did not choose to address teachers?

We all know that most of our teachers live a miserable life because of poor salaries and struggle to survive through private tuitions ?
Modi obviously is not a disconnect from the present situation: “It is rather sad that not many students today want to take up teaching as a profession…”
Wouldn't it have been apt for the government to find ways to compensate the teachers on this auspicious days than rather interact with the children?

Was Modi Politicising Teachers’ Day ?

Modi’s detractors accuse him of playing politics on this solemn occasion of Teacher’s Day. That he was rather too keen to nurture a constituency for himself than anything else. (Can we say it is a rather too far- fetched imagination that Modi now aims at the 2019 when the next general elections are due and millions of these school children will attain voting age?)
This brings me to the question that I raised earlier. Indeed, there is a need of some pep talk from a top ranking leader – a Prime Minister – for school going children. This, indeed, is a welcome move. Yet, why couldn’t Modi wait for the Children’s Day to deliver such an address?
Modi’s politics has all along been against the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty. Remember, he avoided naming Nehru in his very first Independence day speech from the ramparts of the Red Fort though he did name (Mahatma) Gandhi, Sardar (Vallabhbhai Patel) and late Prime Minister (Lal Bahadur) Shastri for their contribution to the development of India. He even announced disbanding the Planning Commission – a brainchild of Jawaharlal Nehru!
There is no doubt about Prime Minister Modi’s great oratorical skills. Perhaps he is one of the most powerful speakers of modern times. He himself disclosed in his Teacher’s day address that as a youngster he got invitations to deliver speeches, obviously as a pracharak of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh. As the BJP’s star campaigner in the general elections last year, he did held millions spellbound with his mesmerisingly articulate speeches – that catapulted the saffron brigade to the seat of power at the Centre.
So, what next? Can we expect an equally eloquent speech by the prime minister on the importance of love in this violence and terrorism hit society on the next Valentine day? Or, an equally articulate speech on the delays in passing the women’s reservation bill in Parliament, on the next Women’s day?
After all, women and young lovers too are important constituencies. Aren’t they?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

WANTED: A Leader

WANTED: A Leader EDITORIAL NEWS Share on facebook Share on blogger Share on linkedin Share on twitter More Sharing Services 31 WANTED: A Leader June 13, 2012 12:15 PM By Deepak Parvatiyar Do we really have any leader in our country who is above religion, caste, and sectarian politics and yet popular with the masses? Can you name any one name that is acceptable to the majority as a mass leader? My question assumes significance in the wake of what we witnessed last week. First, at the Congress Working Committee meeting the delegates raked up the issue of inaccessible ministers (how can they be leaders if they are inaccessible?) Yet, the most important issue was the lack of unanimity even within the ruling coalition itself over the choice of the next Presidential candidate. Thereafter, the BJP’s Gujarat satrap Narendra Modi delivered a power packed punch to claim the scalp of his little-known-much-discussed and elusive bête noire Sanjay Joshi. (Can Modi ...

Why election manifestos are losing their value and importance in India?

Why election manifestos are losing their value and importance in India? By  Deepak Parvatiyar March 11, 2015 Much ruckus is being made on the coming together of the two diametrically opposite parties, the Jammu and Kashmir People’s Democratic Party and the  Bharatiya Janata Party , to form the government in Jammu and Kashmir. Inarguably they are two uncomfortable allies who in any given circumstances are considered ideologically misfit to join hands lest rule together. The initial jerks in the coalition have already surfaced after the J&K PDP’s mentor and new state chief minister Mufti Mohammed Sayeed arbitrarily decided to release hard-line Kashmiri separatist Masarat Alam from detention, recently. This has put the BJP in the dock and it now cries foul over not being consulted on the issue. The Opposition has even forced adjournments in both the houses of Parliament over the issue demanding an explanation from the BJP-led Union Government. The BJP is ...

Summary of Second Phase of Assam and Bengal polls

Summary of Second Phase of Assam and Bengal polls By Deepak Parvatiyar http://www.elections.in/blog/summary-second-phase-assam-bengal-polls/ April 11, 2016 An FIR was filed against Assam Chief Minister Tarun Gogoi (Congress) under Section 126 of the Representation of People’s Act at the direction of the Election Commission for violating the model code of conduct by holding a press conference in Guwahati during the second phase of polling in the state. The allegations made by Gogoi during the press conference were found unfounded by the Commission which viewed the press conference as an exercise to influence the polling. Voter Turnout in Assam State polls in Assam concluded with 82.02% of 1,04,35,277 voters turning out at the 12,699 polling stations by 5 pm, to seal the fate of 525 candidates in 61 assembly constituencies of the state. The polling percentage was much higher than the 76.05% recorded in these constituencies in 2011 state elections and the 80.21% poll...